Home » A Dilemma

A Dilemma

Photo illustrated by rosipaw

A guest post written by Kathy Schofield

Almost every day I read or hear discussions on what could be considered a dilemma. The dilemma: How does a person know if the health care system or the medicine they are choosing is the right one to solve their problem(s)? The other day I heard an interview with a physician who said that many doctors were no longer prescribing a certain medical test for men because they had found that the test sometimes caused more problems or uncovered conditions that weren’t really difficulties, but led to procedures that were found to be unnecessary.

If someone is looking for answers to their health needs, there are many proposed health care systems: traditional medicine or alternatives such as acupuncture, herbal remedies, physical therapy, the mind-body perception of health, movement therapies, Native American healer/medicine man, Reiki, homeopathy (10th in usage among adults and 5th among children), and many more. What a host of alternatives!

Truly a dilemma.

One of the best solutions I, and many others, have found for solving this dilemma is spiritual healthcare, or prayer, which is not based on changing material conditions. In my case I have chosen to use the system of healing as taught in Christian Science. Although some may say it isn’t a science, its method has been proven over centuries to be effective in healing all types of diseases, beginning even before Christ Jesus (the greatest healer mankind has known so far), What is this system based on? The foundation, or Principle, is God, and the method is prayer to a God that is said to be good, just, and merciful – and most of all – unchanging, reliable, and trustworthy.

Christian Science, discovered in 1866 by Mary Baker Eddy, was thoroughly tested as a prayer healing system before her book, Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures, was written. Eddy knew she couldn’t write about this method unless she had proved that it worked on a regular scientific basis. In the Preface to her book, Eddy says, “Since the author’s discovery of the might of Truth in the treatment of disease as well as of sin, her system has been fully tested and has not been found wanting; but to reach the heights of Christian Science, man must live in obedience to its divine Principle.” It could be said that living in obedience to its divine Principle is equivalent to following the procedures used to prove a new scientific discovery. Don’t deviate from the rules that have already proved to be true, the solution to the problem will always be the same. Could it be that a spiritual healthcare system is the Science that will solve this dilemma?

As our nation continues to explore and research answers to this dilemma, wouldn’t it be just, since it seems there is no one right solution, to let individuals participate in a health care system that gives them the choice to use the health care that has proved most effective for them?

About the author

Guest We are pleased to present Notes from the Field authors, who are assistant committees and church members in the Southern California region; and Notes from The Mother Church authors, who are Committees from the United States and around the world, as well as the Federal Committee on Publication office.

Email This Page
Print Friendly

6 Responses to “A Dilemma”

  1. Diane says:

    I agree with this bloggers choice of dilemma solutions. I have been implementing Christian Science care for 10 years now and have found it to be quite effective. Though I had known and read Christian Science literature since a teenager, when I was diagnosed with many problems and given a list of medications to take from a physical required for insurance changes (and my premium shot up in cost), I decided to give CS a consecrated effort. Occasionally working with a practitioner, praying for myself, and studying the Bible Lesson daily, after a year and a half, I took another physical and my insurance premium was cut in half (taking me to a different tier). My doctor told me whatever I was doing that it was sure working and he hadn’t seen a dramatic change as this ever. I had been able to gradually reduce the use of the prescribed drugs without side effects, change of lifestyle in lessening overeating, alcohol and caffeine were easy and natural, and my whole life became much more satisfying and harmonious.

  2. ann says:

    Thank you for the post, Kathy, and much appreciation to Diane for sharing such a lovely and heartfelt response. I am indeed grateful for your progress, …in personal and spiritual growth in overcoming some difficult challenges through your study and application of Christian Science prayer.

    God does guide, guard and govern!

  3. Mary Lou MacKenzie says:

    Thanks for the great article, Kathy. Aren’t we all glad that we have a choice.

  4. Robin says:

    Well said and well experienced!

  5. Rhonda says:

    Great blog! I just wanted to add that although spiritual healthcare “is not based on changing material conditions,” a harmonious, healing change in material conditions is the natural outcome of spiritual healthcare or prayer as practiced in Christian Science. I use this form of healthcare and have found this to be the result…health and healing!(=

  6. Anne says:

    A wonderful answer to the dilemma that’s out there on the health care issue. I loved your comment about a spiritual health care system, as Christian Science is, being able to solve the dilemma. It’s good to get these thoughts into the public square.

    Thanks, Kathy.